Why Do Magic Erasers Fall Apart? 5 Common Explanations

This site is reader-supported and I earn commissions if you purchase products from retailers after clicking on a link from this site. As an Amazon Associate, I’ll earn from qualifying purchases.

Magic erasers use Durafoam to last much longer than other melamine foam pads. However, they’re not impossible to break. In fact, some people notice their magic erasers fall apart after one or two uses. The good news is there are many ways to prevent this issue from happening.

Magic erasers fall apart because you’re using them with harsh chemicals, you’re scrubbing too hard, or you’re not wetting the foam before using it. Furthermore, a magic eraser might break apart too easily if you’re cleaning an abrasive surface or if you choose a generic brand.

In this article, I’ll break down why your magic eraser falls apart when you use it, how to make it last longer, and how long these durable melamine foam pads should last.

Why Do Magic Erasers Break So Easily?

Magic erasers break so easily for these five reasons:

  1. You’re scrubbing too hard with the magic eraser. These erasers are quite abrasive, so there’s no need to apply too much pressure. Vigorous scrubbing will damage the melamine foaming, causing it to become brittle and break apart. It’s better to scrub slow and steady.
  2. The foam isn’t wet enough to use. Wetting the foam prevents the dryness from crumbling the material. It also stops unwanted abrasive scuff marks that could ruin the surface you’re cleaning. Always run the foam under water for a few seconds before using it.
  3. There are harsh chemicals or stains on the cleaning surface. While you can use some chemicals with magic erasers, many of them are too harsh. Many modern cleaning supplies will crumble and corrode a magic eraser, so they’re not worth it.
  4. You might be using a low-end magic eraser. Apartment Therapy explains generic brand magic erasers don’t come close to the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser. They’re not made with the high-quality Durafoam, which means they’re only good for a couple of uses.
  5. The cleaning surface is too abrasive for the melamine foam. Magic erasers can be used on a variety of surfaces, but anything abrasive will undoubtedly weaken the material. For example, asphalt and concrete can break a magic eraser apart.

The Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is the best option when it comes to melamine foam pads. These foam pads come in a 10-pack that can remove grease, grime, and stains from numerous surfaces. They’re up to four times more durable than most generic brands, and they’re quite easy to use.

Magic erasers work on grease, grime, and many other substances. However, they quickly clog from these spills. It’s important to rinse the magic eraser before storing it; otherwise, the substance will slowly corrode the melamine foam.

How Long Should a Magic Eraser Last?

A magic eraser should last anywhere from one to ten uses, depending on the surface and the toughness of the stain. If you’re cleaning a rough surface with heavy stains, such as shower grout, you might need a couple of magic erasers.

On the other hand, if you’re removing small bits of baked food or cleaning a glass top stove with a magic eraser, you’ll likely get multiple uses out of it. The same applies to using magic erasers and other melamine foam products on crayon marks, mold, and other non-abrasive substances.

The biggest disadvantage of magic erasers is that they’re incredibly porous. This loose construction means they don’t last as long as traditional sponges (the yellow or green kind you use on kitchen dishes). However, they get the job done much quicker.

You might notice the melamine foam crumbling around the edges. Once this happens, it’s time to get a new one to prevent the old foam pad from making a mess.

On the bright side, there’s a lot you can do to get the most out of your magic eraser. You can make it last for several uses before replacing it. If you’re interested in learning a few tips and tricks, read on.

How Can I Make My Magic Eraser Last Longer?

To make a magic eraser last longer, try these suggestions:

  • Use a natural spray to lift the stains and wipe them with a paper towel. You could also try Mr. Clean All Purpose Cleaner. It’s made by the same company that makes the Magic Eraser. Spray a small amount of this solution on the surface, wait for a few minutes, then scrub it with the magic eraser.
  • Always soak and wring out the magic eraser before using it. While you can try the previously mentioned solution, most messes don’t need anything other than the magic eraser. However, Clean Heart Maids claims you have to thoroughly soak and wring the sponge to prevent it from falling apart.
  • Don’t apply too much pressure to the melamine foam. Gently scrub any surface you’re cleaning. You’ll have to spend a few more minutes on the mess, but you’ll save the magic eraser in the process. You’ll also prevent the surface from getting scuffed by the melamine.
  • Never cut sealed melamine foam pads. Whether you’re using a magic eraser on fabric, glass, or grout, it’s important to use it in its original condition. Cutting the foam loosens it, increasing the chances of it breaking apart. Furthermore, you’ll have less cleaning foam to work with.
  • Dry your magic eraser before storing it. Melamine (the primary ingredient in magic erasers) can develop mildew and mold. Soaking a magic eraser and not drying it being putting it away is a surefire way to ruin the foam and make it unusable.

Magic erasers are built to last for a long time. However, improper usage or poor storage routines could ruin them much earlier than you’d think. Tough jobs might call for a couple of magic erasers, but why not try these suggestions to make them last longer?

Wrapping It Up

All in all, magic erasers are excellent cleaning tools. Using them correctly will prevent the magic eraser from breaking apart too easily. Make sure you soak the foam in water before using it, and never apply harsh chemicals to the surface if they’ll damage the pad.

Jonah

Jonah enjoys finding new DIY methods to fix common problems around the house. If he's not writing for one of his blogs, he's likely playing acoustic guitar, listening to audiobooks, or watching movies.

Recent Posts